Managing risks associated with the software and applications used for daily operations is crucial in today's interconnected business environment. This aspect of Third-Party Risk Management (TPRM) focuses on the corporate supply chain, specifically the digital tools and services organisations rely on.
This article provides a comprehensive guide on defining the scope and objectives of your TPRM programme. We break down complex concepts into clear, actionable steps, ensuring you have a well-structured approach to setting up a programme that addresses your organisation's unique needs.
Defining the Scope of a TPRM Programme
The initial step in establishing a TPRM programme is clearly defining its scope.
This involves identifying which software applications, digital services, and IT vendors you’ll include in your risk management efforts.
To effectively define your scope, consider the following factors:
- organisational structure and industry: The size and nature of your business significantly influence the scope of your TPRM programme. For instance, a small e-commerce business might focus on a limited number of critical software applications, such as their e-commerce platform, payment gateway, and inventory management system. On the other hand, a large financial institution will consider a broader range of applications, including customer relationship management (CRM) systems, trading platforms, risk analysis tools, and regulatory compliance software, but also organisations such as clearing houses, law firms and other partners that handle sensitive data on their behalf.
- Nature of third-party interactions: Evaluate how different applications and partners interact with your organisation's data and systems. Consider factors such as:some text
- Access to sensitive data
- Integration with critical business processes
- Potential impact on business continuity
- Frequency and volume of data exchange
A healthcare provider, for example, must pay particular attention to any organisation handling patient data, ensuring compliance with health information privacy regulations.
- Regulatory environment: Different industries are subject to regulations impacting TPRM requirements. Financial services companies must adhere to strict guidelines regarding data protection, system integrity as well as use of critical ICT survice providers (e.g. DORA), which expands the scope of their TPRM programme to include all suppliers that handle financial transactions or customer data.
- Risk tolerance: Assess your organisation's appetite for risk. Some companies will adopt a more conservative approach, including a wider range of software applications in their TPRM programme. Others will choose to focus only on the most critical applications. This decision should align with your overall corporate risk management strategy.
- Available resources: Be realistic about the resources you’re prepared to allocate to TPRM. This includes personnel, time, and budget. If resources are limited, you need to start with a narrower scope, focusing on the most critical suppliers, and gradually expand your programme over time.
- Potential business impact: Prioritise suppliers based on their potential to impact your business operations. For example, an e-commerce company will likely include its website hosting service, payment processing system, and customer database in its TPRM scope due to the severe consequences of any issues with these systems to its operations and ability to continue to provide its services.
To illustrate this process, consider a medium-sized financial services firm. They focused their TPRM efforts on their core banking software, customer relationship management (CRM) system, data analytics platform, cloud storage provider, as well as clearing houses and financial messaging services. These were selected because any issues with these systems would severely disrupt their ability to serve customers, protect sensitive data, and meet regulatory requirements. By clearly defining their scope to include these critical applications, they concentrated their resources effectively and managed their most significant digital supply chain risks.
Setting Objectives for a TPRM Programme
After defining the scope of your TPRM programme, the next crucial step is to establish clear, measurable objectives. These objectives serve as the guiding principles for your TPRM efforts, helping to focus your team's efforts and providing a basis for measuring the programme's success.
The importance of clear objectives in TPRM cannot be overstated. They:
- Provide a clear direction for your TPRM team
- Allow for accurate measurement of progress and success
- Facilitate effective communication of the TPRM programme's purpose to stakeholders across the organisation
- Help in aligning TPRM efforts with broader organisational goals
Here are some examples of objectives you should set for your TPRM programme:
- Ensuring compliance: Achieve and maintain 100% compliance with data protection regulations across all third-party suppliers handling customer data within the next 12 months.
- Mitigating specific risks: Reduce the risk of data breaches from third-parties by implementing enhanced security protocols for all critical vendors, aiming for a 50% reduction in weaknesses in any security controls relating to their specific relationship to your business within the next year.
- Improving visibility: Create and maintain a comprehensive inventory of all third-parties, including their risk profiles and integration points, within the next six months.
- Enhancing resilience: Develop and test business continuity plans for all critical third-party providers, ensuring minimal disruption to operations in case of vendor issues, within the next quarter.
- Streamlining vendor management: Implement a standardised assessment process for all new vendors.
- Continuous monitoring: Establish a real-time monitoring system for critical third-party suppliers, capable of detecting and alerting on performance issues or security anomalies within 15 minutes, to be implemented within the next year.
When setting these objectives, adhere to the SMART criteria:
- Specific: Clearly define what you aim to achieve. Instead of a vague goal like "improve software security," specify "implement multi-factor authentication for all third-party applications handling sensitive data.”
- Measurable: Ensure you can quantify progress. For example, "reduce the average time to patch critical vulnerabilities in third-party software from 30 days to 7 days."
- Achievable: Set realistic goals given your resources and constraints. While aiming for "zero security incidents" might be admirable, a more achievable goal is "reduce security incidents related to third-party suppliers by 50% compared to the previous year."
- Relevant: Align your objectives with your organisation's overall business goals and risk management strategy. For a company focusing on rapid growth, an objective is "implement a scalable TPRM process capable of assessing new software vendors within 48 hours to support business expansion."
- Time-bound: Set clear deadlines for achieving your objectives. This creates a sense of urgency and allows for regular progress checks. For instance, "complete comprehensive risk assessments for all existing third-party suppliers within the next 90 days."
Start with a focused set of key objectives rather than attempting to simultaneously address every possible aspect of TPRM. As your programme matures and you achieve initial goals, expand and refine your objectives to address more complex or nuanced aspects of managing your risks.
Best Practices and Key Considerations
Implementing an effective TPRM programme requires adherence to best practices and careful consideration of potential challenges. Here are some key strategies to enhance the success of your programme:
- Secure executive sponsorship: Obtaining support from senior leadership is crucial. Educate executives on the importance of TPRM, highlighting potential risks and benefits. With executive backing, you'll secure necessary resources and drive organisation-wide adoption of TPRM practices.
- Foster cross-functional collaboration: TPRM touches multiple areas of an organisation. Establish a cross-functional team including representatives from your IT security, compliance, procurement and other relevant business units. This diverse team provides comprehensive insights into the risks and operational impacts of any third-party supplier breaches.
- Implement a risk-based approach: Prioritise your TPRM efforts based on the criticality and risk level of different software applications. Develop a risk assessment framework that considers factors such as data sensitivity, operational importance, and the extent of system integration. This allows for more efficient resource allocation, focusing intensively on high-risk applications while applying lighter touch processes to lower-risk software.
- Establish standardised processes: Develop and document clear, repeatable processes for vendor assessment, risk evaluation, and ongoing monitoring. This includes creating standardised questionnaires for vendor security assessments, defining escalation procedures for identified risks, and establishing regular review cycles for all third-party suppliers and partners.
- Leverage automation and technology: Utilise TPRM software platforms to streamline processes, enhance visibility, and improve reporting. These tools automate risk assessments, provide real-time monitoring of vendor performance, and generate comprehensive reports for stakeholders.
- Implement continuous monitoring: Move beyond point-in-time assessments to implement continuous monitoring of your software supply chain. This involves using security ratings services, automated vulnerability scanning, or real-time performance monitoring tools to quickly identify and respond to emerging risks.
- Develop a vendor tiering system: Categorise your software vendors based on their criticality to your operations and the sensitivity of data they handle. This allows for tailored risk management approaches, with more rigorous controls and frequent assessments for top-tier vendors.
- Incorporate TPRM into the software procurement process: Integrate TPRM considerations into your software acquisition workflow. This ensures that security and risk assessments are conducted before new software is purchased and implemented, preventing the introduction of unacceptable risks into your environment.
- Establish clear communication channels: Develop protocols for regular communication with your software vendors. This includes setting expectations for incident reporting, defining points of contact for escalations, and establishing processes for sharing security updates and patches.
- Conduct regular training and awareness programmes: Ensure that all employees involved in managing or using third-party software understand their role in risk management. This includes training on data handling procedures, recognizing security threats, and following incident reporting protocols.
- Plan for continuous improvement: Regularly review and update your TPRM programme. This involves conducting post-incident reviews to identify lessons learned, staying informed about emerging threats and regulatory changes, and soliciting feedback from stakeholders to refine your processes.
Common challenges in implementing TPRM include:
- Resource constraints: Many organisations struggle with limited budgets and personnel for TPRM. Address this by starting with a focused scope, leveraging automation where possible, and building a business case for additional resources based on risk reduction and operational improvements.
- Vendor resistance: Some vendors are reluctant to participate in extensive security assessments. Overcome this by clearly communicating the importance of TPRM, potentially offering incentives for compliance, and being prepared to re-evaluate relationships with uncooperative critical vendors.
- Complex supplier ecosystems: Large organisations often have thousands of suppliers, making comprehensive TPRM challenging. Tackle this by implementing a phased approach, starting with the most critical applications and gradually expanding your programme.
- Keeping pace with technological changes: The rapid evolution of technology makes it difficult to maintain an up-to-date TPRM programme. Address this by fostering a culture of continuous learning, regularly reviewing and updating your risk assessment criteria, and maintaining close relationships with your IT and security teams.
- Balancing security with business agility: Stringent TPRM processes tend to slow down procurement and onboarding. Mitigate this by developing streamlined assessment processes for low-risk applications and working closely with business units to understand their needs and timelines.
Remember, TPRM is an ongoing process that requires regular attention and refinement. It's about progressively improving your risk management capabilities rather than achieving a perfect state. Regularly review the effectiveness of your programme, learn from any incidents or near-misses, and be prepared to adapt your approach as your organisation's needs and the threat landscape evolve.
Conclusion
Defining the scope and objectives of your TPRM programme is a critical first step in managing the risks associated with the third-parties that your organisation relies on. By carefully considering your unique operational needs, regulatory requirements, and risk tolerance, you can create a TPRM programme that effectively protects your business from the complexities and risks in your corporate supply chain.
The key to success lies in starting with a clear understanding of what needs protection and what you aim to achieve. From this foundation, you can then build a programme that evolves with your business and the changing technology landscape. While it's important to be comprehensive, don't be deterred by the scale of the task. Begin with a focused approach on your most critical software applications and expand methodically over time.
Further Reading
